20 November 2026

Some Moriori Migration Lore

From Moriori: A People Rediscovered, by Michael King (Penguin, 2017), Kindle Loc. 5280ff.:

The following traditions accounting for the Moriori presence in the Chatham Islands and the sequence of settlement there is reprinted from Alexander Shand’s The Moriori People of the Chatham Islands, Memoir of the Polynesian Society, volume II, Wellington, 1911, pp. 100–119.

The first canoe of which the Morioris have any tradition was Kahu’s (Ko ro waka a Kahu), and of this story there are two versions. The people of the north end of the island hold that Kahu arrived first at Kaingaroa Harbour, where he planted his fern-root (aruhe) at a place named Tongariro. This was called Kahu’s fern-root, and was known as such until after the arrival of the Maoris in 1836, when it was destroyed by pigs. Another name for fern-root was ‘Kahu’s root’ (Te aka a Kahu), a simile. There was a difference between his fern-root, it is said, and the ordinary kind. That of Kahu had a very light fibre (kaka), and when the outside rind was scraped off, was white and soft; it was evidently a finer variety, not having the strong yellow fibre of the ordinary kind.

He brought with him his god — Kikokiko — also named Kahu, which he secreted at Rangikapua, the point on the western side of Kaingaroa Harbour. He also brought the kumara (sweet potato), which he planted on the island, but it would not grow. This was the karakia (incantation):

Kumara no Aropawa i ko
Kumara na rau toro, tinaku e.
Homai e i ahu ai o wahine ti.
E kaha, takina na rau toro, tinaku e.

Kumara from distant Aropawa,
Kumara of the spreading leaves, increase (or grow deep);
Come, be heaped up by the (your) junior wives,
Be strong, spring up the spreading leaves, increase.

By this recital, which is a very ancient one, it will be seen that the Morioris preserved the knowledge of the kumara plant in their isolation. Beyond the fact of its having been brought here, they knew nothing more, until told of it by the Maoris on their arrival in 1836. Prior to this, on seeing potatoes brought to the island by the early ships, they said they were kumara; also called pakamara. It would appear from this that both Moriori and Maori carried their seed kumara, &c., with them on their journeys, and they must have had canoes (or perhaps vessels) constructed so as to keep them safe from sea water, which would have rotted them. The Morioris fix the date of Kahu’s arrival in the time of their autochthone ancestors Kahuti and Te Akaroroa, who lived at Kaingaroa; of Maripane, who lived at Matarakau; of Tamakautara, who lived at Te Awapatiki; of Karangatai and Karangatua, who lived at Whangaroa; and of Tapeneke and Taponi, who lived at Waitangi. The name of the canoe was said to be ‘Tane,’ and the crew were hokoru(a) (forty in number). Some of the old men appeared to be in doubt as to the name, and referred to it generally as Kahu’s canoe — Ko ro waka a Kahu. On arrival, Kahu found the island in an unsettled state — kauteretere (floating) — and he joined together some places, and separated others.

...

The next canoes to arrive at the island were Rangihoua and Rangimata. The cause of this migration, they say, was fighting in Hawaiki. There appear to have been various take (causes) of disturbance. First, the troubles of Manaia; second, the killing of Rakei; third, the burning of Ta-Uru-o-Monono or Manono. The last trouble, which caused the immediate departure of these canoes, arose through one Tama-te-kohuruhuru, son of Tu-moana, who killed his wife or sweetheart, Papa, in a fit or rage, because she accused him of impotency.

Tu-moana’s tribe was named Wheteina, and it is evident from the story that they lived in pretty close proximity to the Rauru tribe, to which Papa, or Tahu, and her father Horopapa belonged. It would appear that, although said to be of different tribes, they both were evidently of the same stock, and related to one another, as Tu-moana called Papa his son’s sister (no doubt a cousin of some kind or other), and Horopapa he speaks of as his uncle. On discovering the murder of his daughter, Horopapa and his people surrounded the house of Tu-moana, his son, and people at night, and killed them all, with the exception of Tu-moana, who escaped into ‘his thickets’ (hitiki), and hid there for some time. Tira, his brother-in-law connived at his escape. (Tira was a younger brother of Horopapa, and married Tu-moana’s sisters — a Ra Puhi rau ko Ro Pua —Te Puhi and Te Pua.) Tu-moana, after this, gathered his people and commenced fighting with the Rauru tribe. One of the Wheteina, Koro-wahia, lying in ambush in the hollow of a totara tree (Podocarpus totara), killed Tira, which added fuel to the fire. Horopapa then sent to fetch his elder brother Hapa-kiore (all three were sons of Tchura-huruhuru = Maori Tuara-huruhuru), who gathered all their tribe, the Rauru-motchihere, or -motuhake — the true Rauru — to fight with the Wheteina and their allies. The battle took place on the sand-beach of Whanga-patiki (said by the old men to have been a short one, not more than half a mile in length). One of the headlands was called Tauranga, the other Tapuika. The Rauru occupied the Tauranga, and Tu-moana, with his allies, the Tapuika end of the beach. The latter people were exceedingly numerous, covering the beach, hence Horopapa’s proverb —‘Tapuika is dark, Tauranga is light’ (Ka po Tapuika, ka ao Tauranga), in allusion to the multitude of Tu-moana’s people, and the few of the Rauru. The names of the tribes who assisted Tu-moana were Ruarangi, Muturangi, Wheteina, Harua, Tch-Eitara, Makao-a-uha, Makao-a-to(a), Matanga, Poutama, Tch-Eituhi, Tch-Etikoke and Tch-Etiao or Etiaw’(a). They fought, it is said, until the sea on the shore was red with blood, and in the end the Rauru defeated Tu-moana and his people. The account is vague as to how long the fighting was going on previous to the battle; but during that period the canoes Rangihoua and Rangimata were being built, and they put to sea during the fight. Rangihoua was not properly completed when she was launched, though Rangimata was. To this fact they attribute the former’s ill-luck in getting ultimately wrecked, and in consequence very little is known about her people, of whom only a few were saved. All the legends and karakias concentrate around Rangimata and her arrival at the island. Although it is said Tu-moana and his tribal allies were defeated, it does not appear from a further part of the account that they were so completely. When Rangimata was afloat with Rangihoua, before setting forth on her voyage, the Rangimata people recognised the voice of Kirika, elder sister of Tu-moana, reciting the incantation of girding the marowhara (Pikinga i ri marowhara) of her brother. After recording this, the story says, Ka torikirikitii Ta Uru Manuka (‘Ta Uru Manuka became small in the distance’).

Their home left, they ‘set out to live or die’ (Pokai ta uru o te whenua, pokai ta uru o te moana), to wander round the crown of the land, to wander round the crown (expanse) of the ocean, to arrive after all their wanderings at the Chatham Islands. It is evident from the accounts that they endured severe privations on the way, particularly in the case of the Rangihoua canoe, whose crews were dying from lack of food and water, and in their helpless condition were wrecked on the north coast of the island, at Okahu. Another canoe, called Pouariki, made at the same time as Rangimata and Rangihoua, was said to have left with them, but, beyond this statement, nothing more was heard of her after leaving. From the short account given of her, however, she appears to have been a double canoe of some kind, having a consort, ‘Katoko’ by name — He whakapiri no Pouariki (‘An adjunct’— lie close together — ‘of Pouariki’). As the Moriori raft-canoe was not in the least like this, of which the tradition alone is preserved, it is evident that the original canoes or vessels in which they came here from Hawaiki were entirely of a different character to any thing now in use either by Moriori or Maori. With Pouariki was another canoe, Poreitua, whose consort (whakapiri) was named Mano, which came likewise, but, as in the case of Pouariki, nothing further is known of her.

...

19 November 2026

Finding Sources on Moriori

From Moriori: A People Rediscovered, by Michael King (Penguin, 2017), Kindle Loc. 5920ff.:

A major difficulty needs to be registered in relation to the first two chapters. The only relatively reliable evidence about the pre-European Moriori comes from the visit of the British naval vessel Chatham to the northern coast of Chatham Island in 1791; and from the activities of professional archaeologists. All else — including later accounts of Moriori traditions and European observations — is less sound, because it records information long after events took place. As Rhys Richards has pointed out, the major observers of early Moriori life — Frederick Hunt, Johannes Gottfried Engst, William Baucke and Alexander Shand — did not even arrive at the Chathams until thirty-five, thirty-seven, forty-three and fifty years respectively after regular contact between Moriori and European had begun. That is a considerable time lapse. Further, there are virtually no contemporary descriptions of the effects of the presence of sealers on Moriori life between 1805 and 1835, and much of what can be said about that period is speculation based on slender evidence.

As far as the rest of the nineteenth century is concerned, it is probable that no part of New Zealand has had so much unsubstantiated rubbish written about it as the Chatham Islands. I have read and discarded much from secondary sources that turned out to be either pure invention on the part of the writer, or the consequence of repeating earlier errors, or the result of the writer being subjected to practical jokes by Chatham Islanders. Hence there are no stories here about sailors from Callao, Peru, thrashing the Moriori, nor of early Portuguese colonising the islands before Broughton’s arrival. I have tried wherever possible to work from primary sources, and primary sources that can be shown to be reliable. Where I have doubts about the value or validity of evidence, these are noted in the text or in the source notes that follow.

For the events of more recent years, I have relied more heavily on oral informants than I would normally for a book of this kind. This is partly to compensate for the paucity of other forms of documentation of Moriori life in the twentieth century. But it is also a recognition that oral communication and oral history are still strong forces in the Chathams, which (at the time of writing) lacked television to absorb family evenings. People still talk with one another there far more and far more often than they do on mainland New Zealand. Evening discussions in most homes are long and detailed, sometimes contentious, sometimes hilarious. A man such as David Holmes of Waitangi absorbed and repeated stories he heard while working with Charlie Seymour in the 1920s; Seymour had arrived in the islands in 1866; David Holmes’ stories, therefore, cover a combined period of more than 120 years of first- and second-hand experience, as do those of Rose Swann (née Ritchie), whose father landed on Chatham Island in 1864. Here too I have opted wherever possible for accounts of first-hand experience in preference to second, third, fourth or fifth; and I have depended most heavily on informants noted for their honesty and reliability.

I am grateful to the Chatham Islanders for their ability to talk; and for their willingness to do so to an outsider in the interests of giving history a more permanent form.

18 November 2026

Moriori Mixed Legacies

 From Moriori: A People Rediscovered, by Michael King (Penguin, 2017), Kindle Loc. 3241ff.:

TAME HOROMONA REHE, KNOWN LATER AS TOMMY SOLOMON, WAS born on 7 May 1884 at Waikaripi on the west coast of Chatham Island. His antecedents were a combination of the Owenga Moriori tribe, who had settled the east coast of Chatham Island south of Te Awapatiki, and the Otonga people of the south-west coast. His grandmother Nakahu, originally from Owenga, had met his grandfather Purehe, from Otonga, on Pitt Island. They had been taken there by Maori captors to cultivate land. After the release of slaves these grandparents returned to the main island to live primarily at Owenga and bring up their two children: Paranihia Ngamare, born in 1853, and Rangitapua Horomona, Tame’s father, born in 1856. They remained there until their deaths. But the Rehes always regarded Waikaripi on the Ngaio coast as their ancestral home. They lived there in a ponga hut for a few months of each year and used it as a base for birding expeditions up the Tuku Valley, which kept alive their ancient hunting rites. It was during one of these west coast sojourns that Tame Horomona was born.

...

If the community to which Tame Rehe belonged was Moriori by descent, its culture, however, was not. The Moriori language was no longer used there (even Tapu employed it only in the course of his scholarly investigations with Alexander Shand). Normally the inhabitants spoke Maori and some English. Their sources of Moriori tradition were Tapu and his wife Rohana, and these tended to be tapped only when evidence was required for claims in the Native Land Court. Rangitapua had shown some interest in becoming a repository for Tapu’s knowledge in his early years; and he had published at least one article on the Moriori creation and arrival myths in the Maori language newspaper Te Korimako in 1883, when he was twenty-seven. But while Rangitapua viewed his Moriori identity as a feature of the present, he saw Moriori traditions as a thing of the past. His perspective was forward-looking; he was determined to pull his people out of the trough into which an obsession with the past had plunged them previously. Like Hapurona Pawa, Riwai Te Ropiha, Tamihana Heta and others of their generation, he was a practical man who reluctantly accepted the tragic history of his people and the findings of the Native Land Court. He had put these disasters behind him and sought to secure the physical and economic well-being of his family as best he could within the resources available.

The Chatham Islands ‘culture’ of the late nineteenth century was an amalgam of Maori and European elements shaped by the islands’ isolation from mainland New Zealand. Most Maori and Moriori spoke Maori and some English; some Pakeha, such as Thomas Ritchie, spoke Maori. Fashions were casual in the extreme, except when a special occasion — a dance, a reception, the Waitangi races — called for dressing up. Funerals and tangihanga were conducted according to local custom. On ordinary days, boots and shoes were to be seen only in Waitangi — and then not frequently.

Chathams people had by this time turned in upon themselves. The prosperity that had seemed likely in the 1860s had not eventuated and the islands were hit hard by mainland economic depressions and the high cost of shipping stock and wool out and goods in.

...

They grew their own fruit and vegetables, the latter in common plots. Meat was available from their own sheep. Cod and paua were taken from the rocks when the weather permitted. And there were periodic family foraging expeditions for eels, flounder, swans’ eggs and ducks from Te Whanga. Further afield, the annual mutton-birding expeditions up the Tuku Gorge produced hundreds of birds for preserving. The annual seasonal expeditions to the Sisters, the Forty Fours and the Pyramid, undertaken with Maori and other Moriori, brought back albatross and mollymawk chicks. The Manukau community worked hard for its sustenance; but it was well fed. And older members, such as Tapu, Rohana and Tehume, were always given a share of the fruits of foraging.

Six years after Tame was born the first school opened on Chatham Island, at Te One. He was enrolled and attended periodically from 1890 to 1896, sometimes from Waikaripi and at others riding the twenty kilometres to and from Manukau. He learnt to read and write and displayed a general intelligence well above average. There was no thought that he should pursue his studies, however. His father pulled him out of classes at the beginning of 1897 to help him work the land at Manukau, and to look after his mother, who was by now overweight and chronically ill. At this age and throughout his adolescence, Tame coped easily with everything that came his way. School had taught him to read, write and count, and that was as much as he wanted from it. He grew into a fit and good-looking young man, not tall (1.74 metres) but muscular. He had no trouble with the physical side of farm work (his father was clearing land and planting additional pasture for sheep). He was a powerful back in the Owenga rugby team. And from his mid-teens he was regarded as sufficiently strong and responsible to join the older men on birding expeditions.

17 November 2026

Reclaiming the Chathams

From Moriori: A People Rediscovered, by Michael King (Penguin, 2017), Kindle Loc. 2220ff.:

While Ritchie’s Moriori friends and workers were writing to him about life’s mundanities and pains, an equally fluent but weightier correspondence had been going on for a decade between Moriori leaders and representatives of the Government in New Zealand. Few of these letters have survived, making those that have all the more precious; their content and manner of expression have allowed the Moriori to send significant and enduring messages to their descendants and to a wider posterity.

Sir George Grey was Governor of New Zealand from 1845 to 1853, and again from 1861 to 1868. Although he waged war against a variety of Maori tribes during both terms, he won the respect of the Maori — adversaries and friends — for the fact that he learnt their language and recorded their history and traditions at length. Even when making submissions to the ‘Kawana’ that turned out to be hopeless and pointless, Maori with grievances at least felt that they were being heard and understood. No other Governor had been able to give that impression.

There is no evidence that Grey met Moriori petitioners although it is likely that he did so on the Auckland Islands in 1850. At the very least the Moriori there would have seen Ngati Mutunga chiefs conferring with the Governor and would have known that they were in affectionate correspondence with him. Further, Grey would have known something of the Moriori plight from Hane Te Rau (Jane Brown), a Ngati Mutunga rangatira and daughter of Te Rau O Te Rangi, one of only three women who signed the Treaty of Waitangi. She was sister-in-law to Wiremu Naera Pomare and an adopted daughter of the chief Apitea Punga, who eventually left her all his property at Owenga. She was also a forceful and intelligent woman who served for a time as George Grey’s secretary and — it was rumoured on Chatham Island — his mistress. She went to South Africa with him and returned to New Zealand with the Governor in 1861.

There is a mystery about the first Moriori document sent to Grey. It is dated 22 April 1859 and signed by six elders from Otonga, a tribal area in the southwest of Chatham Island. It is made up of historical and genealogical information about the Moriori, and its purpose seems to be to distinguish them from the Maori occupants of the Chathams. It is a Moriori attempt at self-definition — and the earliest one that survives in writing — and descendants of the authors believed it was sent to Grey to convince him that the Moriori were the rightful owners of Rekohu. Its language is Maori (but for a few short karakia in Moriori), the dialect Taranaki (apparent particularly in the dropped h’s), though with some specifically Moriori words and usages.

16 November 2026

Chatham Islands Sheep Runs

From Moriori: A People Rediscovered, by Michael King (Penguin, 2017), Kindle Loc. 1970ff.:

The mid-1860s brought a new class of settler to the Chathams. Although sheep had been introduced to the islands in the early 1840s, and the German missionaries had raised them with some success, no one other than Frederick Hunt on Pitt had attempted to exploit them in quantity. And it was Hunt, visiting Canterbury in search of new markets for his meat and wool, who drew the attention of pastoralists there to the sheep-running potential of the islands. Although they lacked pasture, except where it was being slowly won from bushland, they had large areas of fern on peat known locally as ‘clears’, and it was these that would initially provide the bulk of Chathams grazing land.

The first of this second wave of European colonists to live on Chatham Island was Thomas Ritchie, an ebullient and shrewd Northern Irishman. He had reached Lyttelton in 1863 at the age of nineteen, and came on to the Chathams in February of the following year. He took up land at Okawa, under the patronage of the local Ngati Tama chief Heremaia Katene Te Raki. He grew potatoes and raised cattle to trade with American vessels and bring in an immediate income, while at the same time he cleared and fenced land in preparation for sheep, which he eventually bought from Frederick Hunt.

Ritchie worked hard and rapidly expanded the range of his operations. By 1866 he owned 9,300 hectares from Owenga to Te Awapatiki, which his brother Robert farmed. And he was to lease a further 4,450 hectares from Kaingaroa to Te Awapatiki. On the shore of Lake Te Wapu, he began in 1867 to build Lake House, the most luxurious and envied residence on Chatham Island to that time. Eventually he was running a total of 16,000 sheep on these properties and on a third, on the Ngaio coast south of Waitangi, known as the Tobacco Country.

Ritchie’s genius was that he recognised and pursued any money-making opportunity. He quickly became a trader (with a store at Owenga) and a shipping agent, and he operated a salvage business. He was a voracious sportsman and organised shooting competitions and the first horse races on Chatham Island. The jockey club, which he founded in 1874, is the oldest in New Zealand to have functioned continuously. He also introduced game birds.

Ritchie was successful in these early years because he was also a good employer. His relations with his Maori lessors were good. He was a down-to-earth character with no sense of superiority, and he was happy to offer work to Maori and Moriori farmhands and stockmen. This combination of qualities produced one of the most astonishing collections of private papers in New Zealand: a large group of letters in Maori from Maori and Moriori correspondents that extends over sixty-three years (Ritchie left the Chathams in 1923 and lived until 1934).

Other sheep-farming settlers who, like Ritchie, arrived in New Zealand to find the Canterbury runs all taken up, stocked and staffed, also came on to the Chathams. They included James Hay, who went into partnership with the Ritchie brothers, Walter Hood, Howel Pattison and Edward Chudleigh.

Chudleigh, from a family of Cornish gentry, arrived in the islands in 1866 and took a long lease of land on the Wharekauri block along the northern coast. Like Ritchie, he was a strong character and became one of the best-known personalities on Chatham Island and its first justice of the peace. Unlike Ritchie, he exuded an air of sanctimonious superiority and pettiness and — although he became the island’s most successful farmer — his relations with his Maori, Moriori and European neighbours and employees were almost always strained. Chudleigh at times romanticised the ‘old-time, noble Maori’ and even had a Maori costume in which he used to pose and posture. But he never learned to speak Maori, he never had Maori in his home, and he hated having to visit Maori and Moriori dwellings and communities.

Though very different in character and mannerisms, Ritchie and Chudleigh were to dominate settler activities on the island for the next quarter-century. And life was hard for both of them. Clearing farms and maintaining them, in weather that was often atrocious, was back-breaking; getting wool out to the mainland markets was difficult and sometimes dangerous. Bales had to be taken beyond the surf line in drays, loaded onto boats, then ferried out to waiting ships. On one occasion, in 1868, Chudleigh and his men spent all day on this exercise and were soaked and exhausted at the end of it. Shortly afterwards they heard that the ship had gone down and the entire cargo lost.

...

Indeed, getting to and from the Chathams was part of the hazardous business of living there. Shipwrecks were frequent (thirty-four recorded between 1840 and 1868) and employees, friends and family were as likely to be lost as cargo (Frederick Hunt farewelled one of his sons onto a ship that was never seen again). Transport around Chatham Island itself, and between Chatham and Pitt, was almost equally dangerous, and there is a long list of drownings and near-drownings in the 1860s and 1870s, of broken limbs, and of horses becoming bogged or throwing their riders.

15 November 2026

First Magistrate of Chatham Islands

From Moriori: A People Rediscovered, by Michael King (Penguin, 2017), Kindle Loc. 1766ff.:

Archibald Watson Shand, who arrived at Chatham Island in July 1855 to become the first resident magistrate and collector of customs, wrote to [George] Selwyn that same year while the bishop was on the island, explaining to his lordship how things were (and describing scenes which might have been concealed from episcopal eyes):

...

The resident magistrate adds his disappointment that even Wi Tamihana, the catechist in Waitangi, kept several slaves, and he asked Selwyn to ‘prevail on him to not only set a better example in general for the future — but in practical proof of his sincerity, to begin by liberating his slaves.’

Shand took a census the same year. It revealed that the Moriori population was now down to 205: 106 men, 76 women and 23 children (the figure still, of course, excludes those on Auckland or Stewart Islands; and those who are of mixed Maori-Moriori blood, who were classified as Maori). Maori numbered 300, and ‘Europeans’ 64, including six Tahitians, four Portuguese, two Spaniards and two North American Indians (most of the latter had come off ships to join the shore whaling gangs).

This decline in Moriori population, which was to vary from seven to ten per cent per annum in the years that followed, was too steep and began too early for there to be any possibility of a major recovery a few years later when slavery was relaxed and Moriori morale rose and the Maori population as a whole began to increase. By 1860, the population of pure-blooded Moriori was headed irreversibly towards extinction.

The following eight years were nightmarish for Archibald Shand, who was a fastidious but ineffectual man. The Maori kept promising to behave — to obey the laws, to moderate their drinking, to cease plundering one another, to observe customs procedures, to stop beating their slaves, even to release their slaves — and just as promptly broke these promises. A land-loan dispute with the German missionaries led to their ignoring the resident magistrate’s authority and refusing to comply with such laws as the registration of births. Shand for his part had no authority other than a moral one. There was no one, Maori or European, on whom he could rely to enforce his authority or even to risk friendship. While everybody on the island wanted their lives and property protected, they did not want the submission to procedures that was part of the social contract with the New Zealand Government. The Chathams had already evolved a culture that was independent (and suspicious) of mainland New Zealand and its bureaucracies. Almost all Shand’s Maori appointees as tidewaiters (to collect duty from visiting ships) and constables let him down and were themselves guilty of infringements of the law.

To compound these problems, Shand was trying to raise his large family (eight children born before he reached the Chathams, four more on the island) as British ladies and gentlemen. He was horrified at the poor example they received from their fellow citizens, and despairing of their ever being able to find suitable husbands and wives among the riff-raff Europeans cast up on the island (largely seamen who had jumped ship); for his offspring, a union with a Maori was unthinkable and one with a Moriori never even considered. At times, after he had tried to discipline recalcitrants, he feared that the family’s physical well-being could be in as much danger as their virtue.

14 November 2026

Christianity Reaches the Chathams

From Moriori: A People Rediscovered, by Michael King (Penguin, 2017), Kindle Loc. 1392ff.:

Peace was sealed late in 1842 when a party of Church of England Maori missionaries arrived in the Chathams and converted most of Ngati Tama and Ngati Mutunga en masse. Many of those who were not persuaded were mopped up the following year by the Reverend John Aldred, a Wesleyan, who established loyal followings of Maori and Moriori at Hawaruwaru and Tupuangi. Only the Ngati Kuri hapu of Ngati Mutunga remained aloof from both denominations.

Although there was inevitably some doubt about the depth, understanding and sincerity of such rapid conversions, the adoption of Christianity did have one immediate and long-term benefit for the Moriori: while most remained enslaved, it brought to an end the callous and spontaneous killings with which their owners had, up to this time, been able to terrorise them. From 1842 Moriori lives were still nasty and brutish; but they were not as short as they had been previously.

In spite of a gradual improvement in their circumstances, and of their apparent docility in the eyes of European observers, the Moriori remnants were never reconciled to the events of 1835 and their aftermath. Their view of what had taken place was simple and unequivocal. Their mana whenua (which arose from at least half a millennium of occupation of Rekohu) had been ignored by the Maori, but had never been extinguished. They had not been defeated in fair contest, as they had not engaged in a contest. They had been dealt with neither as owners of the islands, nor as the partners they had been prepared to be. Their offer to share the resources of Rekohu with those who were, after all, distant Polynesian kin, had been hurled back in their faces. They had been ignored, insulted, slaughtered and enslaved — brought to their knees physically, culturally and spiritually. But because they had neither broken Nunuku’s injunction nor vacated their island, their own mana was intact.

..

Had they possessed an intimate knowledge of Maori tribal culture in 1835, however, Moriori would have known that the outcome of the Ati Awa invasion was inevitable, given that they declined to defend themselves. This was particularly so in the light of the previous decade of Ngati Mutunga and Ngati Tama history. For these Maori at this time, displaced from their own ancestral home and insecure in their previous one, mana was to be derived almost solely from fighting, and even more so from successful conquest. There was the additional fact that the Moriori were dealing with what Rhys Richards has called ‘a post-European Maori culture … strong tribal organisation was kept, as was communal living in well-built fortified villages [pa]; but, with the aid of European guns, gods and potatoes [the latter permitting more mobile campaigns and longer sieges], warfare was elevated to an even more important role in their lives’.